[Being an Amazon Affiliate, when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.]

Best Carbon Monoxide Detector Consumer Reports Reviews Smoke Detector in 2020

For quick decision, the Google Nest Protect Alarm-Smoke Carbon Monoxide Detector is the best carbon monoxide detector consumer reports.

Carbon monoxide is a potentially fatal gas produced by boilers and water heaters installed in the home. The carbon monoxide detector is the best protection against this danger. Some models can also detect smoke. But before buying, find out about the battery life (7 or 10 years), the alarm, the presence of the test and pause button as well as the certifications. So which carbon monoxide detector to choose?

List of Best Carbon Monoxide Detector Consumer Reports

Below are the top recommendation for the good quality best carbon monoxide detectors consumer report / wirecutter.

  1. X-Sense Carbon Monoxide Detector Alarm, CO Alarm Detector Model CO03D
  2. Google Nest Protect Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm
  3. Kidde 21026043 Battery-Operated Combination Smoke/Carbon Monoxide Alarm with Voice Warning
  4. Kidde Nighthawk Plug-In AC/DC Carbon Monoxide Alarm Detector
  5. First Alert SCO501CN-3ST Battery Operated Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm with Voice Location

1. X-Sense Carbon Monoxide Detector Alarm, CO Alarm Detector Model CO03D

This CO detector stands out from the competition by its great affordability, not only in terms of price, but also in terms of ergonomics: it is indeed the only one of our selection to have an integrated LCD screen.

Although it displays the lowest price of this selection, this detector is nonetheless competitive thanks, in particular, to its integrated LCD screen. While the latter is designed to clearly communicate to you the general condition of the device, it especially allows you to consult the carbon monoxide concentration at any time of the day.

Like the other models in this selection, it works with batteries and, more specifically, with 3 AA batteries (1.5V) which must be replaced when used up.

To know when you will need to make this change, you just have to rely on the detector, because it is he who will send you a message to warn you that the batteries are low, as well as to inform you that its sensor electro-chemical (designed to last 10 years) comes to the end of its life.

Concretely, this ability to communicate is largely made possible by the presence of an LCD screen. More than a “simple” indicator of correct operation, it is primarily used to inform you about the level of CO captured in the surrounding air, with a measurement updated every 10 seconds.

Thus, if the concentration rate reaches 30 PPM for more than 120 minutes, the 85 dB alarm will go off, to warn you of the danger.

You can of course make it silent, by pressing the Test / Pause button, but we do not recommend that you do so, because although this function is useful for smoke detectors , it is more dangerous when it is activated . This is CO which is odorless and colorless: you will not be able to perceive its presence and therefore will not be able to determine whether or not it is harmful to your health.

In the end, this easy-to-install model (and, moreover, supplied with screws and dowels) has everything to please the greatest number. For good reason, not only is it affordable, but it is also very efficient since it has high-performance reactivity.


2. Google Nest Protect Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm

Not only is it the best option on the connected detector side, but it is also the best option on the versatile device side, acting as both a CO detector and a smoke detector.

Although the price is not the most affordable, it is justified by the connected nature and the dual function that only this device can boast . Compatible with the Google Nest Learning thermostat, which we already presented to you in our dedicated article , the latter very precisely locates the danger, to communicate the origin to you in a written and / or oral way …

As with our best mid-range, there are 6 AA batteries that are designed to last around 10 years. Note that if you are not convinced (e) by the effectiveness of these, you can always turn to the wired version which offers, of course, more reliability but much less freedom as for the installation. This is in fact all the more the case as the brand recommends a ceiling configuration.

As you can imagine, this ease of use does not allow this detector to establish itself as a safe bet. On the other hand, its dual-spectrum sensor contributes greatly to its singularity since in addition to being able to detect the excessive presence of CO in the air, it can also detect slow and / or fast combustion smoke. , like a real smoke detector.

The other particularity of this model is of course its connected nature. Thanks to it, you will be able to consult the results of self-diagnoses (carried out more than 400 times a day) on your smartphone and will even be able to find out about the state of the battery, as well as the correct functioning of the sensors.

Carbon monoxide or smoke, these will never fail to trigger the 80 dB alarm, in the event of a potential danger. You will then be notified either by notification or orally, thanks to the integrated speakers. The voice will also tell you the exact source of the problem.

Better still, if you choose to set up an interconnected system (you can connect up to 18 devices), the voice messages will be broadcast on each of the detectors. Thus, the detector installed in your room will, for example, be able to warn you about a possible concentration of CO in the kitchen.

A good point which undeniably gives the Nest its interesting quality / price ratio. Endowed with a connected nature, it benefits from a great precision which gives you the possibility of being aware of any risk, well before it does not harm your health or your life. In addition, it will also integrate perfectly into a pre-existing Google ecosystem.


3. Kidde Smoke/Carbon Monoxide Alarm with Voice Warning

If you’re still not sure where to buy the best carbon monoxide detector, we invite you to take a look at Kidde. This sign is recommended for the reliability of its products, such as this model. With this material, you will be awakened even in the middle of the night if ever too strong an emanation is detected. This is thanks to the powerful alarm with which this specimen has been equipped. This engages at a volume of 85 dB.

On the other hand, an alert will also inform you of the battery status. This will let you know when you need to change them. You will then always ensure the proper functioning of your equipment.

In addition, this item has a long service life. Indeed, the designer manufactured it so as to accompany you for ten years. This will allow you to put some money aside to get a new one when the time is right.

Easy assembly: The mounting bracket is delivered with this equipment.

Loud alarm: The sound level of the latter is 85 dB. This value is more than enough to wake you up in your sleep in case of danger.

Longevity: This device is able to support you effectively over a period of 10 years. An alert will activate at this time to remind you to change the device.


4. Kidde Nighthawk Plug-In AC/DC Carbon Monoxide Alarm Detector

The dependable Kidde Nighthawk is a top pick for a carbon monoxide alert. This module model highlights an advanced perusing of current carbon monoxide levels (likewise alluded to as CO) and it’s revived like clockwork. The unit incorporates a 9V battery reinforcement for significant serenity and kept observing on account of a force blackout.

The simple to-peruse advanced showcase is up front on this alert. Numerous analysts value having the option to see the CO level initially, and this data could be helpful to people on call in case of a hole. A catch named ‘Pinnacle Level’ makes it simple to review the most elevated recorded degree of CO since the alert was last unplugged or reset.

You should surrender an outlet to connect this carbon monoxide caution, yet the significant serenity that the Kidde Nighthawk gives is well justified, despite all the trouble. Furthermore, the unit incorporates additional rope, so you can plug it into an outlet and set the unit on a close by table, rack, or counter.

There are various rave audits about this carbon monoxide finder and a lot of stories with respect to how it made families aware of risky CO levels. In any case, a particularly helpful component is the way that the unit can be unplugged and conveyed into various spaces for a moment perusing, on account of the locally available battery reinforcement. The Kidde Nighthawk is a solid, valuable carbon monoxide alert that can keep you secured.


5. First Alert SCO501CN-3ST Battery Operated Combination Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm with Voice Location

First Alert SCO501CN-3ST is a battery-worked blend smoke and carbon monoxide indicator. Accordingly, it can distinguish both smoke from flames and carbon monoxide levels. It must be introduced on the roof or on dividers. The best component here is the adjustable Voice Location include. That component permits you to set up explicit orders for various areas around the house. Thusly, when there’s smoke or carbon monoxide identified, the alarm will initially give you a voice warning of which room is influenced and by what. Accordingly, you don’t need to go from space to room attempting to sort out where the caution is ringing.

The smoke alarm utilizes photoelectric smoke detecting innovation and the carbon monoxide sensor utilizes electrochemical sensors. Them two are profoundly exact and trend setting innovations. There’s a different LED pointer for carbon monoxide and for smoke. At the point when carbon monoxide levels arrive at a basic level, the gadget will blare multiple times and delay before signaling once more. That is the carbon monoxide caution and it rings at a 85dB volume so it’s noisy enough. This gadget likewise accompanies a Silence button in the event that you need to kill the alerts.

You should, notwithstanding, note that there is no presentation screen on this carbon monoxide indicator. Accordingly, you will be advised when the CO levels get basic, however you can’t perceive what the levels are in ppm. Besides, before arriving at basic levels, you can’t perceive what the carbon monoxide levels are. You likewise don’t gain admittance to the CO levels history. Besides, this carbon monoxide identifier can’t be matched with a cell phone so you can possibly screen it when you’re in its region.

There have likewise been a few reports of bogus cautions. A large number of the gadget’s previous clients have noticed that it begins going off for no obvious explanation. Moreover, since this is a mix smoke and carbon monoxide finder, you can’t introduce it in the kitchen since it will continually continue ringing.

In light of everything, First Alert SCO501CN-3ST isn’t the most solid or best carbon monoxide identifier available. This is maybe one of the main battery-worked blend carbon monoxide indicators that is accessible at such a modest value, which is the reason I have recorded it here. In any case, it doesn’t have a showcase for observing, nor does it have brilliant similarity. The absence of the two makes it difficult to screen. Moreover, there are such a large number of reports of bogus cautions to excuse, and that is disturbing.


Why buy a good carbon monoxide detector

Your safety and that of your family

The figures speak for themselves. More than 3,000 people are victims of carbon monoxide poisoning each year, of which about 100 die. Dangerous, this gas remains odorless, colorless and invisible. So to avoid serious poisoning, even death , equip yourself with a CO detector is essential. Especially if you use a water heater or a boiler at risk.

This gas usually comes from the combustion of fossil materials such as gasoline, fuel oil, wood and coal. If you use gas or oil-fired water heaters, as well as gas stoves, wood or pellet fireplaces, wood stoves, flue boilers or charcoal barbecues, the risk is very high. Only a carbon monoxide detector can warn you of abnormal levels.

Avoid carbon monoxide poisoning

Often, this gas causes headache, asphyxiation and loss of consciousness. Carbon monoxide poisoning can be fatal in high concentrations or prolonged inhalation. Symptoms are flu-like, including mild headache, fatigue, nausea and vomiting. It can quickly develop into a severe headache and drowsiness, which can lead to death.

In order not to get to this stage, the only solution is to install a carbon monoxide detector, not just a smoke detector that warns in case of fire. This device can quickly detect the presence of this toxic gas in the air even before the first symptoms appear.

Avoid attempted theft

Not only does this device save your life, but it can also prevent you from attempted theft. Indeed, some burglars use this gas to put occupants to sleep. The sound signal sent by the detector quickly warns of the high presence of CO and can thus deter thieves and scare them away. In short, you have to be prepared for any eventuality, because an informed man is worth two!

Interconnected detectors

Wired or wireless?

It is possible to interconnect certain smoke and carbon monoxide detectors. This allows the units in the house to sound the same alarm when one of them goes off. In some recent homes there is already wiring to connect the detectors. If not, you are purchasing detectors that can interconnect wirelessly.

House on one or more levels?

Interconnected smoke and carbon monoxide detectors are especially useful if you live in a multi-story house. For single-storey houses, stand-alone detectors are more than sufficient.

What are the limits ?

While interconnected alarms can make your home safer, they do have certain limitations. In many cases, only detectors of the same brand can connect to each other. So check with manufacturers or sellers compatible models, including within the same brand.

Despite the limitations, the best is the use of interconnected detectors. They will warn you before the fire or carbon monoxide spreads. Wired or wireless, the interconnected detectors enhance home security. Obviously, this comes at a cost.

Installation of a carbon monoxide detector

Do you really need it?

Since 2016, the smoke detector is mandatory in many territory. For the carbon detector, it mostly depends on the equipment you use. Indeed, all homes are not exposed to the same risks. Everyone has to decide whether they need it or not.

To do this, determine if your home has combustion heating systems such as wood, oil and coal stoves. Open fireplaces are also a danger. The same goes for mobile oil-fired auxiliary heaters as well as gas or oil-fired water heaters.

The location

Install a carbon monoxide detector in every room with a combustion device such as the water heater and gas or oil furnace. We can mention the kitchen, the living room, the bedrooms or the bathroom . For remote boilers, it is better to place the detector outside the boiler room but always in the home so that the alarm remains audible.

Ideally, place the carbon monoxide detector 1 to 3 m horizontally from the source. For bedrooms, the detector must be close to the headboard.

The pose

Carbon monoxide detectors are often sold with mounting screws. Thus, you can install them on the ceiling 30 cm from the wall, or on the wall between 10 and 15 cm from the ceiling . Remember to attach the detector more than 1 m from any device that may emit carbon monoxide or water vapor. Also avoid the proximity of aeration or ventilation.

For detectors with LCD display, avoid mounting them to the ceiling unless the height is relatively low. And place them at chest height so that you can read the directions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which carbon monoxide detector to choose?

Based on our research, most users consider the Siemens Delta Reflex 5TC1260 to be the best carbon monoxide detector on the market. And the qualities of this model prove them right.

What is carbon monoxide?

Carbon monoxide is an odorless gas, invisible to the naked eye and non-irritating. This makes him particularly dangerous. All homes equipped with gas or oil boilers and water heaters are subject to carbon monoxide fumes. And if you happen to use a generator inside the house, this problem affects you too.

How to choose a carbon monoxide detector?

Consider the certifications, sensitivity and battery life. You will also need to choose based on the size of your home, the number of potentially hazardous equipment, and features.

If you already have smoke detectors, stand-alone alarms won’t really help. For diaper rooms or the bathroom, opt for a carbon monoxide detector with digital display.

What are the different types of carbon monoxide detectors?

There are simple CO detectors, conventional stand-alone alarms and connected stand-alone alarms. These have smartphone apps and can send alert messages, diagnostic reports or light up the room in your presence.

What is the lifespan of a carbon monoxide detector?

The best carbon monoxide detectors have a lifespan of 7 or 10 years. Some models need to change the battery every year. On average, change the detector every 5 years, regardless of whether it is still working. Indeed, these devices lose sensitivity over time.

How do you install a carbon monoxide detector?

Most current models accept all installation configurations: to put on a piece of furniture, to fix on a wall or to fix to the ceiling. Place the detector at a horizontal distance of 1 to 3 m from hazardous equipment.

If you attach it to the ceiling, install it at least 30 cm from the wall. If you fix it on the wall, keep a distance of at least 15 cm from the ceiling.

How much does a carbon monoxide detector cost?

Entry-level models cost less than 40 euros. The mid-range vary from 40 to 100 euros. As for high-end carbon monoxide detectors, they are worth more than 100 euros.

What is the right number of carbon monoxide detectors for a home?

It depends on the layout and size of the house. You should have at least one CO detector on each floor. That said, it’s a good idea to place one outside of every bedroom so that every member of the family is sure to hear the alert if it goes off.

You should also place a carbon monoxide detector 1 to 3 m from your boiler or any fuel-fired heat source.

Is a carbon monoxide detector with digital display safer than other types of detectors?

A digital carbon monoxide detector is often the best option for keeping your home safe, as it tells you even the smallest real-time fume rate.

What should I do if my carbon monoxide detector issues an alert?

Get out of the house immediately. Transport those with symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning to hospital. If you are unable to leave the house, open as many windows and doors as possible and call for help. If possible, turn off all possible sources of carbon monoxide.

Leave a Comment