7 Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports

One of the main advantages of owning a homemade best ice cream maker is the opportunity to prepare wholesome desserts at any time. These devices are available in various sizes, styles, and price ranges. Because using an ice cream maker can be tricky, you should refer to our useful tutorial on how to use an ice cream maker. Before shopping for one, you ought to first have a clear belief of what you want.

A portable ice cream machine is a terrific option if you want to start preparing cold desserts and frozen treats at home. They are easy to use, affordable, and no longer require plumbing or electricity. You will be able to make whatever ice cream flavor you like. This frozen dessert machine turns simple ingredients into a creamy and delightful frozen dessert. These devices normally have simple controls and functionalities that are simple to use and may be controlled by anyone.

Appliances with an electric motor make a lot of noise. In this aspect, people are frequently worse violators than others. Those who are touchy to loud gadgets must study the opinions earlier than creating a purchase. To assist potential buyers, customers quickly mention how noisy an ice cream machine is in their reviews.

Ice cream makers may be discovered in numerous sizes. These range in size from little ice cream machines for men and women to huge ice cream makers capable of producing a half-gallon at a time. These machines have a dial that controls round and five-velocity characteristics.

In addition, this dial has a preset call that indicates the speed at which the ice cream maker will churn the ice cream. Below, we have selected the most demanded and handpicked products that are best for you, so now go and grab your favorite product.

List of Best Ice Cream Makers Consumer Reports

  1. Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker
  2. Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker
  3. KitchenAid KICA0WH Ice Cream Maker
  4. Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker
  5. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE Electric Ice Cream Maker
  6. Chefn 5255870 Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker
  7. Cuisinart ICE-45P1 Ice Cream Maker

1- Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

The easy-to-use control panel with an LCD screen has three settings for soft-serve ice cream, frozen yogurt, and gelato and controls the speed to suit your needs. Ice cream is packed with flavor and fun, making it an ideal treat for family and friends.

This easy-to-use ice cream maker is great for creating ice cream in no time at all. You can easily prepare the perfect batch of healthy frozen desserts with a countdown timer without worrying about running out of time. The control panel displays accurate temperatures and timing so you can make your treats with ease.

The paddle has a wider diameter that causes it to mix more thoroughly to ensure that all ingredients are evenly incorporated. The motor automatically shuts off when the ice cream is frozen, saving you valuable time and energy.

This ice cream maker features a digitally controlled motor to consistently smooth, double-churned ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, and sorbet. The durable brushed chrome finish resists fingerprints and scratches with ease. Designed for easy use, the compact design makes it a snap to store when not in use.

A compact, simple-to-use ice cream maker produces delicious ice cream in minutes. It’s the perfect way to make fun and delicious frozen desserts and treats at home. The compact size takes up minimal space in the kitchen, so you can maximize counter space where you need it most. A convenient control panel makes it easy to operate. Includes recipe booklet and an instruction manual.

2- Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE21R Ice Cream Maker

The Cuisinart ICE 21R is a great choice for making creamy, delicious ice cream. This feature alone is a big help in keeping the delicate ice cream from melting. The large spout on the lid is a great feature for squeezing extra liquid when packing the containers. A fully automatic ice cream maker means no manual work is necessary to create your favorite dessert. A great feature is an additional container that can make additional batches of ice cream at once.

An easy way to make delicious desserts, kids will love to help with the mixing and choose their flavor combinations. A convenient ice cream maker for when you want to indulge in a sweet treat but don’t have time to whip up a batch at home. These fun frozen treats are also great for parties or any get-together when you’re pressed for time. A convenient mix and store feature keeps the fun going.

Make frozen treats and desserts in 20 minutes or less with this durable and versatile Cuisinart ice cream maker. It features a two-tiered double-insulated stainless steel freezer bowl that makes it easy to prepare a wide variety of frozen treats. It’s also dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. The large capacity makes up to 1-1/2-quarts so that you can make up to four batches at once.

Enjoy frozen desserts and drinks made in less time with this handy and innovative appliance.  The machine can accommodate a 2.5-liter continuous flow bowl with a spout to add ingredients without the bowl from the base.

3- KitchenAid KICA0WH Ice Cream Maker

KitchenAid KICA0WH Ice Cream Maker

The secret to perfect ice cream is within the simplicity of the appliance. Just prepare your mix in the bowl through swift and easy kneading and turn on the switch. It will loosen and lift your frozen treat from its mold into a new shape that is ready to enjoy at the touch of a button. The removable ice-cream bowl creates the perfect scoop. 

When it’s time to clean, simply rinse out the bowl under running water or in the sink, and let it air dry before putting it away. Unfortunately, this Cream Maker Attachment is not compatible with 1Qt and 5Qt ice cream machines that have been modified for use with an ice cream maker attachment.

The KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment transforms your mixer bowl into a complete ice cream maker. Simply pour in the frozen ingredients, turn the power on, and the KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment will churn the mixture for you.

The King-Size Bowl is made of heavy-duty plastic and has a smooth surface that will not scratch or stain. The included 3-cup Baking Dish, and 2-cup Baking Dish attachments fit on top of most standard round pans to cook pancakes, waffles, and more. Quickly make homemade ice cream, gelato, or sorbet with ease.

4- Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

Expect the highest quality ice cream maker from Breville when you purchase this Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker. Made in the United States, this ice cream maker will provide you with a consistent product every time you use it. In addition, this machine has an automatic shut-off feature that will turn the machine off if the temperature gets too hot or too cold. 

This ice cream maker has a built-in thermometer, so it will alert you if the freezing process is not working correctly or if the temperature of the product is getting too high or too low. This ice cream maker also comes with a bowl scraper, making it a breeze to clean your ice cream maker. Finally, with a digital timer that lets you know when to add ingredients for your frozen treats, this ice cream maker will have you enjoying homemade ice cream in minutes.

The ice cream maker machine can churn out soft-serve ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, sorbet, or hard ice cream. The machine works using a self refrigerating compressor and has 12 hardness settings for you to experiment with. If you don’t have a freezer to keep the frozen treats in, you can also use the machine to freeze the treats and store them in the freezer later.

A sleek and contemporary ice cream maker that makes some of the best ice creams you’ve ever tasted. This machine is incredibly easy to use, it’s easy to dial in your recipe, and it gives you the perfect texture every time. Just fill the bowl with ice cream, freeze it for at least 8 hours and then pull it out of the freezer once it starts to get soft. Next, mix with a handheld blender or food processor. 

5- Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE Electric Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE Electric Ice Cream Maker

Let the summer fun begin! Make your favorite ice cream and frozen yogurt flavors in minutes with this Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker. This electric ice cream maker will make delicious ice cream, frozen yogurt, and gelato flavors that you can enjoy all year long! Using up to 4 quarts of chilled liquid, this electric ice maker makes quick work of the job. The see-through lid lets you keep an eye on the making process without opening.

Nostalgia is known for innovative, fun, and quality products that give you the ultimate ice cream and frozen yogurt experience. Go back to the days when you could pick up a block of ice cream at your local ice cream shop or make your own from scratch.

The Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker includes a plastic bucket with a see-thru lid with a removable rubber ring and a plastic scraper that’s great for scraping-out messes.

Nostalgia makes classic ice cream with a new twist. Store leftovers in the freezer and less time is spent waiting for your next ice cream fix. Ice cream is made and frozen in just 30 minutes.

This innovative electric unit makes smooth and creamy 4 quarts of delicious frozen sweets in just 30 minutes. A see-thru lid keeps you in control of the ice cream, so it doesn’t harden in storage until ready for serving. You can also prepare up to 3 quarts of treats at once.

6- Chefn 5255870 Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker

Chefn 5255870 Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker


If you’re looking to make ice cream, frozen yogurt, or other frozen desserts, you can make them in minutes with this fully featured unit. The freezer compartment features an easy release mechanism that allows for the easy removal of the dessert once the frozen dessert has been made. Perfect for any occasion, this multi-functional set includes everything needed to make delicious ice cream in minutes.

Ice-Cream and frozen desserts are perfect treats that are easy to make and stay fresh for days. The versatile and easy-to-use Chef’n Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker lets you make delicious homemade ice cream in minutes.

This attractive and attractive ice cream maker is a great way to enjoy a sweet treat with family or friends at any get-together. A built-in spoon and scoop make dessert preparation even easier. In addition, the removable instant dessert pan features an 11.38 inches diameter making it perfect for ice cream treats.

The patented built-in thermometer features a digital display that shows the actual temperature inside the freezer. Simply pour your favorite ice cream or frozen dessert recipe into the pan and follow the easy, step-by-step instructions. Once frozen, the micro-chipped timer automatically turns off the unit to ensure no ice cream melts before it is ready. 

7- Cuisinart ICE-45P1 Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-45P1 Ice Cream Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-45P1 Mix Serve 1.5-Quart Ice Cream maker is the perfect appliance for all ice cream lovers. Cuisinart has a tradition of making reliable and quality appliances, so they have become one of the top brands in the appliance industry.

It has an easy-lock lid with window, mixing arm, one 1/2-quart freezer bowl, three condiment containers, ON/OFF power dial, and cone holder. The double-insulated freezer bowl helps keep the bowl cool and even temperature, so there is no need to worry about the consistency and taste of the ice cream.

Ice-cream maker mixes ingredients according to your chosen ice-cream recipe, making it easy to make delicious homemade ice cream. Simply add the ingredients, lock the lid and let the machine do the rest. This machine uses a special soft-serve process that allows you to use only half the ingredients compared to traditional hand-crank ice-cream makers. 

This allows you to create more of your favorite flavors and enjoy them more often. The unit is equipped with an ON/OFF power dial and an ON/OFF switch. With its double-insulated freezer bowl, it keeps the bowl cool for up to two hours after you turn off the machine. This ensures you will never have an empty bowl of ice cream that has been sitting out too long.

And the machine is equipped with a double wall to keep the bowl cool and at a very even temperature. In addition, the machine has three condiment containers, an ON/OFF Power Dial and a cone holder that you can easily customize your ice-cream flavor.

Best Ice Cream Makers Wirecutter Buyer Guide:

Freezing style:

Mostly frozen yogurt makers use a cooler bowl or supplement that must be chilled before stirring the frozen yogurt. If you don’t have access to a cooler, this is probably not a good idea, plus you’ll have to trust that the bowl will freeze again if you want to form another clump. Similarly, frozen yogurt manufacturers use the ancient ice and salt freezing method.

Settings and Options: 

The most important frozen yogurt machines may have a simple on/off switch. Clocks, scheduled shut-off or “stay cool” features, additional cooler dishes, gelato settings, exceptional oars, and that’s just the beginning of what different machines have to offer. Blower-style frozen yoghurt producers, on the whole, are designed with more controls and options for creating various frozen yogurt styles from various models.

Machine Size:

It’s important to note that frozen yogurt makers aren’t a necessary part of most people’s kitchens, so justifying their purchase may be challenging. The vast majority, on the other hand, enjoy a scoop or two of chilled, exceptionally smooth frozen yogurt throughout the year, so provided you can find a model that fits in your extra space, a frozen yogurt maker will likely be a pleasant addition to your kitchen.

Power source:

Source of Energy Producing frozen yogurt is as simple as adding the ingredients, pressing the start button, and waiting until it’s done because electric frozen yogurt machines handle all of the agitating for you. Other hands-off kitchen gadgets, such as slow cookers, have a similar interaction.

Leave a Comment